Skip to main content

Table 3 Study characteristics

From: The effect of behavioural interventions targeting hand hygiene practices among nurses in high-income hospital settings: a systematic review

Characteristic

References

Setting

 Intensive care unit (ICU)

Fox; Erasmus; Huis; Boyce

 Medical unit

Stock; Huis

 Surgical unit

Erasmus; Huis

 Mixed medical-surgical unit

Stock; Harne-Britner; Boyce; Stella

 Paediatric unit

Huis

 Progressive care/step-down unit

Boyce; Stella

Sample type (HCWs)

 Nurses only

Erasmus; Fox; Stock; Huis; Boyce

 Nurses and nursing assistants

Harne-Britner; Stella

Sample size (HCWs)

< 20

Erasmus

 20–40

---

 41–60

Stock

 > 60

Harne-Britner; Huis; Stella

 Unknown

Fox; Boyce

Sample size (observations)

 < 100

 

 100–500

Erasmus; Harne-Britner

 501–1500

Stock

 1501–2500

---

 2501–5000

---

 > 5000

Huis; Boyce; Stella

 Unknown

Fox

Behavioural frameworks, theories, and approaches

 Behaviourist Theory

Harne-Britner

 Change Theory

Harne-Britner

 Field Theory

Harne-Britner

 Health Action Process Approach

Erasmus

 Social Cognitive Theory

Harne-Britner; Huis

 Social Norms (Behavioural Economics)

Stella

 Toyota Kata

Boyce

 Not listed

Fox, Stock

Study design

 Before-after

Stock; Fox; Erasmus

 Case-control

Harne-Britner

 Cluster randomized control

Huis

 Quasi-experimental w/ interrupted time series

Boyce; Stella

Assessment of compliance

 Direct observation

Stock; Fox; Erasmus; Harne-Britner; Huis

 Electronic monitoring system

Boyce; Stella

Length of Study

> 6 months

---

 6 months

Erasmus; Stella

 12 months

---

 14 months

Huis

 15 months

Fox

 16 months

Stock

 > 2 years

Boyce

Country

 Europe

Stock; Erasmus; Huis

 North America

Fox; Harne-Britner; Boyce; Stella

Assigned methodological quality score

 6

Erasmus; Harne-Britner; Boyce; Stella

 7

Fox; Huis; Stock